A-politicism

From the very beginning, NUAUS declared itself to be essentially a-political. The objects as drafted by the sub-committee which produced the proposed Constitution at the 1937 Adelaide conference included the rider that ‘in no circumstances shall the Union directly or indirectly support any political or religious movement or organisation except so far as shall be necessary for the furtherance of the foregoing objects’. Although the Union’s support for the War effort in 1940-45 was in a sense deeply political, that constitutional principle was consistently interpreted during the later 1940s and 1950s as precluding any political stance whatsoever.

This was, of course, challenged by NUAUS involvement in the two major international bodies, IUS and ISC. Part of the argument against membership of the former, indeed, was that its aims and objectives were inherently political, and that its leadership was firmly committed to the Communist cause. Even ISC, though, voted on many political questions, often relating to decolonisation, and NUAUS delegates found it necessary to abstain.

This stance did not go uncontested. In a thoughtful paper in 1953, International Vice-president Lindsay Colquhoun argued that in the eyes of others ‘the very fact that we do NOT take direct action as students against our Government means that we are all in favour of what our Government is doing’, and that this was in itself a political stance. He did not receive much support for his view.

By 1957, however, Council was prepared to pass a resolution declaring that ‘NUAUS lends its full support to student unions in all countries, whether colonial, dependent or otherwise, in their moves towards the granting of full educational opportunity.’ This carefully-worded motion restricted the union’s commitment to the position of ‘students as such’, which now became the acid test for any political statement. Even a motion of the same Council condemning the situation in Eastern Europe confined itself to the status of student organisations.

Nowhere did this resolute a-politicism cause more difficulty than with regard to the White Australia Policy. This was an issue which undoubtedly affected Asian students in Australia, but even so a chairman’s ruling in 1955 that to take any position as a Union would be unconstitutional made it impossible for a stand to be taken. The furthest the Council could go was to urge students to debate the issue, and encourage constituent bodies to conduct referenda.

The great change in the union’s position on political issues came with the 1961 revision to the Constitution which, while retaining the original rider about support for any political or religious creed, movement or organisation, introduced a commitment to defend ‘the right of all persons to education on the basis of equality without regard to race colour sex economic circumstances political religious or ideological conviction or national or social origin’, ‘freedom of thought expression action and association’, and several more principles along the same lines. This still precluded the union’s tying itself ideologically, but it gave Council and Executive much more room to take up political positions on issues which fell within the scope of the new constitutional espousal of freedom.

Increasing student activism during the 1960s, especially over conscription and the Vietnam war, enabled the National Union to become more overt in its political statements, although most of the campaigning still took place at constituent level.

Only with the expansion into AUS, the emergence of factional groupings in student politics, and the control of the Union by the Left did the position change fundamentally. Divisions over Middle East policy and support for Palestine, which first emerged in 1967, were a significant factor in the eventual collapse of AUS in 1984.