Debating

The first inter-varsity debating tournament was hosted by the University of Sydney in 1921, long before the establishment of NUAUS, and a dispute over control of debating was a root cause of the failure of the first attempt to create a national union, the Australian University Students’ Union. In 1937 an Australian team debated successfully in Manila, and the Governor of the Philippines presented them with a cup which was appropriately named the Philippines Cup. When the Union took over the organisation of the Australian national competition in 1939, the Cup was adopted as the trophy. The proposal that NUAUS should run the tournament was itself controversial, Sydney holding out for autonomy for the debaters, but they were outvoted by all the other participants in the 1938 event.

Even before this, NUAUS had given debating an international dimension, supporting a year-long world tour by a team including its founder Chester Wilmot, and organising a tour of the Commonwealth in July and August 1938 by a team from Le Moyne College in Memphis, Tennessee, an African-American university. The following year an Australian team visited Canada while a New Zealand team came to Australia. Australian debaters toured New Zealand in 1949, and there were regular trans-Tasman visits from then until 1967.

Normally held in the August vacation, the tournament was one of the most successful of the National Union’s activities. The topics selected provide a fascinating insight into current preoccupations, ranging from ‘That Australia needs a Mussolini’ (1939), through ‘That America’s foreign policy is a threat to world peace’ (1949) and ‘That the newspapers are the “Friends of the People” but the enemies of decent men’ (1957) to ‘That respectability is hypocrisy’ (1967) and ‘That prostitutes are all stuffed up’ (1971).

The Philippines Cup disappeared in about 1960, and a search in 1963 failed to locate it. A new trophy was donated by the New Zealand team which took part in the 1965 tournament. The loss of the trophy was all the more embarrassing because NUAUS had just embarked on a regular exchange of tours with the Filipinos, who visited Australia in 1961 and 1964; there were return visits to the Philippines by Australian teams in 1962 and 1966.

In 1967 debating was incorporated in the first NUAUS Arts Festival, and at the same time a Debates Council was established.

The full list of tournaments is:

1938 Melbourne Adelaide defeated Sydney ‘That
modern civilisation kills personality’ (Winner opposed)
1939 Brisbane Queensland defeated Sydney ‘That Australia needs a Mussolini’
1940 No competition  
1941 Canberra Melbourne defeated Sydney ‘That strikes in wartime should be
declared illegal’  (Opposed)
1942-44   No competition  
1945 Melbourne Melbourne defeated Queensland ‘That the primary purpose of
universities should be the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake’ (Affirmed)
1946 Adelaide Sydney defeated Adelaide ‘That all is lost’ (Affirmed)
1947 Canberra Adelaide defeated Canberra ‘That cultural relations are more
important for maintaining world peace than economic relations’ (Opposed)
1948 Sydney Sydney defeated Adelaide ‘That the 20th century is the century of the common man’ (Affirmed)
1949 Melbourne Melbourne defeated Adelaide ‘That America’s foreign policy is a
threat to world peace’ (Opposed)
1950 Brisbane Sydney defeated Adelaide ‘That dictatorship is the most
efficient form of government’ (Affirmed)
1951 Adelaide Adelaide defeated Western Australia ‘That democratic ideals
are incompatible with twentieth-century conditions’ (Affirmed)
1952 Sydney Sydney defeated Queensland ‘That democracy is a refuge rather
than an inspiration’
1953 Armidale Queensland defeated Melbourne ‘That there is an Australian way
of life’ (Affirmed)
1954 Perth Melbourne defeated Sydney ‘That this House pities its
grandchildren’ (Affirmed)
1955 Adelaide Sydney defeated Tasmania ‘That the individual no longer
matters’ (Opposed)
1956 Brisbane Melbourne defeated Sydney ‘That this country should be
respected rather than liked throughout South-East Asia’ (Affirmed)
1957 Hobart Sydney defeated Adelaide ‘That the newspapers are the “Friends
of the People” but the enemies of decent men’ (Affirmed)
1958 Armidale  
1959 Adelaide Queensland defeated Adelaide ‘That freedom and security are
incompatible’
1960 Sydney Sydney defeated New England ‘That politics and religion are
better kept separate’ (Opposed)
1961 Melbourne No winner
1962 Brisbane Sydney defeated Melbourne
1963 Perth ‘That War promotes Civilisation’
1964 Hobart ‘That racial segregation is a necessary evil’
1965 Adelaide Adelaide defeated New Zealand ‘That punishment is necessary
for Justice’ (Affirmed)
1966 NSW NSW defeated Sydney
1967 Sydney Sydney defeated Adelaide ‘That respectability is hypocrisy’
(Affirmed)
1968 Sydney  
1969 Melbourne ‘That man’s better judgement is blinded by cosmetics’
1970 Hobart  
1971 Canberra ‘That prostitutes are all stuffed up’
1972 Melbourne  
1973